The Round Table: Rory, Patrick Reed and who might replace Dan Hicks?

Each week, we ask our panel of writers, PGA members and golf industry experts to weigh in with their views on the hot topics of the day.

Rory McIlroy won the DP World Tour Race to Dubai by a whisker on Sunday, giving him eight in his career and tying Colin Montgomerie’s record. In your opinion, is Rory the greatest European golfer ever?

Jim Deeks, Fairways Magazine (@jimdeeks): If you mean greatest “European Tour” player, yes, I’d pick Rory over Montgomerie.  If you mean greatest player to come from Europe, I’d have to put Nick Faldo and Seve Ballesteros in a three-way tie with Rory.

Craig Loughry, Golf Ontario (@craigloughry): It’s getting harder and harder to argue against Rory being the best Euro Player ever. Eight Race to Dubai titles, five majors, a career Grand Slam, Ryder Cup success, and sustained excellence over nearly two decades put Rory in incredibly rare company. Seve Ballesteros changed the game in Europe, Nick Faldo has six majors, and Colin Montgomerie dominated the European Tour, but Rory has combined global success, longevity, and influence better than anyone. For me, he’s at least on the Mount Rushmore of European golf already. Another major or two before he’s done likely settles the debate and moves him into the clear No. 1 spot.

Michael Schurman, Master Professional / Hall of Fame member, PGA of Canada: Rory certainly has a strong vote but so does Faldo, Harry Vardon, Seve and Langer. I’ll take Rory’s life-time grand slam to put him at the top but it’s not as simple as I first thought it was.

Hal Quinn, Freelance Writer, Vancouver: He was already there but the eighth DP crown about clinches it for the second-guessers. What’s additionally admirable is that he has grown into the mantle and has become such a force in golf off the course. He has handled global adulation and astounding wealth very well, which is admirable too.

Peter Mumford, Fairways Magazine: Statistically speaking, Rory is the best ever. And the gap will continue to grow since he’s not done yet. Obviously, we can’t know how he might have fared against Seve or Harry Vardon but if I had a few Euros to wager, I’d likely put my money on Seve. I think it would be quite a compelling match.

The conclusion of the DP World Tour season yielded ten golfers who earned PGA Tour cards for 2027, including Patrick Reed, who left LIV Golf last year, then went out and earned his way back. What are your thoughts on Reed returning to the PGA Tour?

Deeks: I am certainly no fan or admirer of Patrick Reed.  There isn’t a single player I loathe more.  I’m sorry he’ll back on Tour and on TV screens next year.  But I can’t deny he earned his way back.

Loughry: I have no issue with it. The pathway was there, and Reed earned his way back through performance rather than politics or special treatment. Whether fans love him or not (as crazy as this sounds, it’s good for golf, it needs a villain), professional golf is better when the strongest players are competing against each other. Reed has always been a controversial figure, but he’s also a proven winner who brings attention and intensity to events. If players who left for LIV are willing to come back and meet the same qualification standards as everyone else, I think that’s a fair outcome. Merit should matter, and in this case it did.

Schurman: Congratulations! Well done, you have withstood a severe test and passed just as any other returnee should do.

Quinn: Talking heads and pundits overuse the expression ‘moving the needle’ but at least they won’t be able to use it about Reed. His presence at a PGA Tour stop won’t sell one ticket or add one pair of eyeballs to a telecast. Too bad he’s taking the spot of some young developing talent.

Mumford: I’m not a fan but have to respect what he’s done and the way he got back to the Tour. He’ll no doubt be a villain but that’s ok, the Tour needs a few of those. Wonder if there’s room for Phil.

Sadly, Dan Hicks, the longtime voice of the PGA Tour on NBC, passed away suddenly last week. What are your thoughts on Hicks’ career, and do you have an inspired choice for who might replace him?

Deeks: At last, I get to say something positive about somebody, albeit in a very tragic context.  Dan Hicks was an outstanding broadcaster, and by all accounts, an equally outstanding guy.  He knew his stuff but never tried to impress you with his knowledge.  He knew his role as anchor was to let the analyst do the analysis but keep the show moving.  He could be amusing but never pushy.  I am SO going to miss him on NBC golf and Olympics.  He and Mike Tirico were in a class of their own.  Who could replace Dan Hicks?  Well, Terry Gannon’s pretty good, and, in my view, so was/is Brian Hammons, whose demotion to Broadcast Siberia was always a mystery to me.  But seriously, I’d love to see the return of Kelly Tilghman, who was a consummate golf broadcaster, and badly treated for an innocent off-hand remark about 20 years ago.  She’d be great!

Loughry: Dan Hicks was one of those rare broadcasters whose presence elevated an event without ever making it about himself. He was classy. His voice became part of some of the most memorable moments in golf, and he brought professionalism, rhythm, and credibility to every broadcast. He’ll be missed by fans across multiple sports, not just golf. As for a successor, probably Terry Gannon who brings a more serious tone. He has extensive golf experience, a calm delivery, and the ability to let big moments breathe. In many ways, that understated style is what made Hicks so effective in my opinion.

Schurman: People like Dan Hicks have very special qualities. Of course, they have to have a voice but a vast knowledge in and out of golf is important. Being camera ‘friendly’ with a great sense of humour is important as is flexibility. Replacements are difficult because of the cult nature of the game. My choices would be Geoff Ogilvie, Stephen Aimes, Scott McCarron, Paul Goydos or Jim Furyk.

Quinn: Shocking and sad in equal measure. The tributes from those who knew him told of a guy you’d enjoy having a Johnnie Walker with. His off-air persona seems to have been more important, rightly so. Liked him for rarely getting in the way of the event and admired him for putting up with Miller for so long. It’s a job of handing off — and counting the number of times Curt Byrum says ‘there’ — and having a smooth American voice (by the way, celebrations still ongoing after announcement that Morgan Pressel not renewed). Terry Gannon has figured it out.

Mumford: Dan was one of the best from any sport. He knew how to smoothly manage a broadcast, when to make a point and when to hand off to the experts. Too many of today’s broadcasters want to hog the spotlight and never know when to shut up. That wasn’t Dan. From all reports he was as well liked off the air as on. As for replacements, I have a long list of unsuitables, but two names that should be in the mix: Terry Gannon, who does play-by-play for the PGA Tour and LPGA on Golf Channel and Shane Bacon, who does a very nice job on the Korn Ferry Tour.

The Round Table
The Round Table is a panel of golf writers, PGA members and industry experts.

Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *